1 PLoS ONE 2011 Vol: 6(7):. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0022495

Comparison of LED and Conventional Fluorescence Microscopy for Detection of Acid Fast Bacilli in a Low-Incidence Setting

Light emitting diode fluorescence microscopes have many practical advantages over conventional mercury vapour fluorescence microscopes, which would make them the preferred choice for laboratories in both low- and high-resource settings, provided performance is equivalent. In a nested case-control study, we compared diagnostic accuracy and time required to read slides with the Zeiss PrimoStar iLED, LW Scientific Lumin, and a conventional fluorescence microscope (Leica DMLS). Mycobacterial culture was used as the reference standard, and subgroup analysis by specimen source and organism isolated were performed. There was no difference in sensitivity or specificity between the three microscopes, and agreement was high for all comparisons and subgroups. The Lumin and the conventional fluorescence microscope were equivalent with respect to time required to read smears, but the Zeiss iLED was significantly time saving compared to both. Light emitting diode microscopy should be considered by all tuberculosis diagnostic laboratories, including those in high income countries, as a replacement for conventional fluorescence microscopes. Our findings provide support to the recent World Health Organization policy recommending that conventional fluorescence microscopy be replaced by light emitting diode microscopy using auramine staining in all settings where fluorescence microscopy is currently used.

Mentions
Figures
Figure 1 : Distribution of positive smear readings.
          *No doubtful/scanty results were reported.
Altmetric
References
  1. Global Tuberculosis Control , (2010) .
    • . . . An estimated 9.4 million people develop TB disease each year and approximately 1.7 million die from the disease [1] . . .
  2. E Ellis; K Dawson; V Gallant; M Phypers; D Scholten Tuberculosis in Canada 2009 - Pre-release Link , (2010) .
    • . . . While the preponderance of TB burden is borne by nations in Asia and Africa, TB remains an important public health concern in high-income as well as low- and middle-income countries globally [2]. . . .
    • . . . In 2009 the province of Quebec reported 195 new and retreatment cases, with an incidence rate of 2.5/100,000 [2] . . .
  3. PM Small; M Pai Tuberculosis diagnosis--time for a game change N Engl J Med 363, 1070-1071 (2010) .
    • . . . Although advances in diagnostics are leading to the introduction of new tests [3], [4], the backbone of TB diagnosis worldwide continues to be smear microscopy . . .
  4. RS Wallis; M Pai; D Menzies; TM Doherty; G Walzl Biomarkers and diagnostics for tuberculosis: progress, needs, and translation into practice Lancet 375, 1920-1937 (2010) .
    • . . . Although advances in diagnostics are leading to the introduction of new tests [3], [4], the backbone of TB diagnosis worldwide continues to be smear microscopy . . .
  5. KR Steingart; V Ng; M Henry; PC Hopewell; A Ramsay Sputum processing methods to improve the sensitivity of smear microscopy for tuberculosis: a systematic review Lancet Infect Dis 6, 664-674 (2006) .
    • . . . As a result there have been several initiatives to optimise smear microscopy including changes in specimen collection procedures, specimen processing, and microscopy techniques [5], [6], [7]. . . .
  6. SR Mase; A Ramsay; V Ng; M Henry; PC Hopewell Yield of serial sputum specimen examinations in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis: a systematic review Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 11, 485-495 (2007) .
    • . . . As a result there have been several initiatives to optimise smear microscopy including changes in specimen collection procedures, specimen processing, and microscopy techniques [5], [6], [7]. . . .
  7. The use of liquid medium for culture and DST , (2007) .
    • . . . As a result there have been several initiatives to optimise smear microscopy including changes in specimen collection procedures, specimen processing, and microscopy techniques [5], [6], [7]. . . .
  8. KR Steingart; M Henry; V Ng; PC Hopewell; A Ramsay Fluorescence versus conventional sputum smear microscopy for tuberculosis: a systematic review Lancet Infect Dis 6, 570-581 (2006) .
    • . . . For microscopic detection of acid fast bacilli (AFB), fluorescence microscopy (FM) using auramine staining has been shown to have 10% higher sensitivity compared to routine light microscopy used with Ziehl-Neelsen (ZN) staining, without compromising specificity [8] . . .
  9. J Bennedsen; SO Larsen Examination for tubercle bacili by fluorescence microscopy Scand J Respir Dis 47, 114-120 (1966) .
    • . . . FM is also more time efficient, with one large study reporting FM to take only 25% of the time required for ZN examinations [9] . . .
  10. T Hanscheid The future looks bright: low-cost fluorescent microscopes for detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Coccidiae Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 102, 520-521 (2008) .
    • . . . Light emitting diode (LED) microscopy is a novel diagnostic tool developed primarily to allow resource-poor parts of the world access to the benefits of FM [10], [11], [12] . . .
    • . . . The spectrum of light produced by LED devices is narrower than that provided by mercury vapour conventional fluorescence microscopes and its wavelength is produced to match specifically the peak absorbance of auramine stains [10] . . .
  11. J Minion; H Sohn; M Pai Light-emitting diode technologies for TB diagnosis: what is on the market? Expert Rev Med Devices 6, 341-345 (2009) .
    • . . . Light emitting diode (LED) microscopy is a novel diagnostic tool developed primarily to allow resource-poor parts of the world access to the benefits of FM [10], [11], [12] . . .
  12. RM Anthony; AH Kolk; S Kuijper; PR Klatser Light emitting diodes for auramine O fluorescence microscopic screening of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 10, 1060-1062 (2006) .
    • . . . Light emitting diode (LED) microscopy is a novel diagnostic tool developed primarily to allow resource-poor parts of the world access to the benefits of FM [10], [11], [12] . . .
  13. S Shenai; J Minion; V Vadwai; T Tipnis; S Shetty Evaluation of light emitting diode-based fluorescence microscopy for the detection of mycobacteria in a tuberculosis-endemic region Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 15, 483-488 (2011) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
    • . . . While the Lumin has received both positive and negative reviews in other studies [13], [15], [18], [30], many of its benefits (including low upfront cost and portability) are less important in most high-income settings. . . .
  14. M Bonnet; L Gagnidze; W Githui; PJ Guerin; L Bonte Performance of LED-Based Fluorescence Microscopy to Diagnose Tuberculosis in a Peripheral Health Centre in Nairobi PLoS ONE 6, e17214 (2011) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
  15. H Albert; Y Manabe; G Lukyamuzi; P Ademun; S Mukkada Performance of three LED-based fluorescence microscopy systems for detection of tuberculosis in Uganda PLoS ONE 5, e15206 (2010) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
    • . . . There are several commercial manufacturers now marketing LED microscopes, but few studies comparing their head-to-head performance [15], [30] . . .
    • . . . This was similar to the user -reviews reported by Albert et al. [15]. . . .
    • . . . While the Lumin has received both positive and negative reviews in other studies [13], [15], [18], [30], many of its benefits (including low upfront cost and portability) are less important in most high-income settings. . . .
  16. LG Lehman; AL Ngapmen Yamadji; F Ngo Sack; CF Bilong Bilong The CyScope(R) fluorescence microscope, a reliable tool for tuberculosis diagnosis in resource-limited settings Am J Trop Med Hyg 83, 906-908 (2010) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
  17. BJ Marais; W Brittle; K Painczyk; AC Hesseling; N Beyers Use of light-emitting diode fluorescence microscopy to detect acid-fast bacilli in sputum Clin Infect Dis 47, 203-207 (2008) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
  18. A Trusov; R Bumgarner; R Valijev; R Chestnova; S Talevski Comparison of Lumin LED fluorescent attachment, fluorescent microscopy and Ziehl-Neelsen for AFB diagnosis Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 13, 836-841 (2009) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
    • . . . While the Lumin has received both positive and negative reviews in other studies [13], [15], [18], [30], many of its benefits (including low upfront cost and portability) are less important in most high-income settings. . . .
  19. A Van Deun; TM Chonde; M Gumusboga; S Rienthong Performance and acceptability of the FluoLED Easy module for tuberculosis fluorescence microscopy Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 12, 1009-1014 (2008) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
  20. W Kuhn; D Armstrong; S Atteberry; E Dewbrey; D Smith Usefulness of the paralens fluorescent microscope adaptor for the identification of mycobacteria in both field and laboratory settings Open Microbiol J 4, 30-33 (2010) .
    • . . . These qualities make them attractive for use in low- and middle-income countries, and they have performed well in evaluations in these settings [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] . . .
  21. Fluorescent light emitting diode (LED) microscopy for diagnosis of tuberculosis: policy statement Link , (2010) .
    • . . . Indeed, the World Health Organization (WHO) recently recommended that conventional FM be replaced by LED-FM in all settings where fluorescence microscopy is currently used, and that LED FM be phased in as an alternative to conventional ZN microscopy in all settings [21] . . .
    • . . . Our findings provide support for the recent WHO policy which recommended that conventional FM be replaced by LED FM using auramine staining in all settings where FM is currently used [21]. . . .
  22. HIV and AIDS in Canada , (2010) .
    • . . . The prevalence of HIV infection in Canada is approximately 0.2% [22] . . .
  23. Carl Zeiss MicroImaging GmbH. "Primo Star iLED". Link. Accessed March 7 , (2011) .
    • . . . The Zeiss PrimoStar iLED microscope (Carl Zeiss MicroImaging GmbH, Jena, Germany) was developed in collaboration with FIND (Foundation for Innovative New Diagnostics) and is a stand-alone microscope that can be used in bright-field or fluorescence LED modes [23] . . .
  24. LW Scientific. Link. Accessed March 7 , (2011) .
    • . . . The Lumin Portable Fluorescent Kit (LW Scientific, Atlanta, Georgia, USA) is a portable objective lens attachment that is used with an existing light microscope (in this study it was used with the Zeiss iLED) [24] . . .
  25. J Minion; S Shenai; V Vadwai; T Tipnis; C Greenaway Fading of auramine-stained mycobacterial smears and implications for external quality assurance J Clin Microbiol 49, 2024-2026 (2011) .
    • . . . Staining of slides and readings with all three microscopes were done on the same day to avoid possible fading of the fluorescent stain [25]. . . .
  26. HD Isenberg Clinical Microbiology Procedures Handbook American Society for Microbiology , (2004) .
    • . . . Slides were reported as doubtful, 1+, 2+, 3+, 4+ or negative at 400x magnification [26] . . .
    • . . . Extrapulmonary specimens were processed using standard procedures [26]. . . .
  27. C Clopper; E Pearson The use of confidence of fiducial limits illustrated in the case of the binomial Biometrika 26, 404-413 (1934) .
    • . . . Confidence intervals were constructed using exact methods for proportions [27] . . .
  28. JR Landis; GG Koch The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data Biometrics 33, 159-174 (1977) .
    • . . . Kappa statistics were used to measure the agreement between readings made using two microscopes, with the same reader evaluating the same mycobacterial smears, while taking into account the agreement occurring by chance [28]. . . .
  29. J Minion; L Brunet; M Pai Fluorescent light emitting diode (LED) microscopy for the detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis Link Approaches to improve sputum smear microscopy for tuberculosis diagnosis , (2009) .
    • . . . An illustration of this is seen in the diagnostic sensitivity we report for all 3 FM modalities, which is lower than the pooled estimates of sensitivity found in a recent systematic review and meta-analysis (84% sensitivity compared to culture as a reference standard) [29] . . .
  30. D Affolabi; G Torrea; M Odoun; N Senou; M Ali Ligali Comparison of two LED fluorescence microscopy build-on modules for acid-fast smear microscopy Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 14, 160-164 (2010) .
    • . . . There are several commercial manufacturers now marketing LED microscopes, but few studies comparing their head-to-head performance [15], [30] . . .
    • . . . While the Lumin has received both positive and negative reviews in other studies [13], [15], [18], [30], many of its benefits (including low upfront cost and portability) are less important in most high-income settings. . . .
Expand