1 BMC Research Notes 2009 Vol: 2(1):25. DOI: 10.1186/1756-0500-2-25

Acute aortic dissection: be aware of misdiagnosis

Acute aortic dissection (AAD) is a life-threatening condition requiring immediate assessment and therapy. A patient suffering from AAD often presents with an insignificant or irrelevant medical history, giving rise to possible misdiagnosis. The aim of this retrospective study is to address the problem of misdiagnosing AD and the different imaging studies used. From January 2000 to December 2004, 49 patients (41 men and 8 women, aged from 18–75 years old) presented to the Emergency Department of our hospital for different reasons and finally diagnosed with AAD. Fifteen of those patients suffered from arterial hypertension, one from giant cell arteritis and another patient from Marfan's syndrome. The diagnosis of AAD was made by chest X-ray, contrast enhanced computed tomography (CT), transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) and coronary angiography. Initial misdiagnosis occurred in fifteen patients (31%) later found to be suffering from AAD. The misdiagnosis was myocardial infarction in 12 patients and cerebral infarction in another three patients. Aortic dissection may present with a variety of clinical manifestations, like syncope, chest pain, anuria, pulse deficits, abdominal pain, back pain, or acute congestive heart failure. Nearly a third of the patients found to be suffering from AD, were initially otherwise diagnosed. Key in the management of acute aortic dissection is to maintain a high level of suspicion for this diagnosis.

Mentions
Altmetric
References
  1. MS Hansen; GJ Nogareda; SJ Hutchison Frequency of and inappropriate treatment of misdiagnosis of acute aortic dissection Am J Cardiol 15, 852-6 (2007) .
    • . . . However, despite major advances in imaging modalities and noninvasive studies, correct diagnosis is not always the rule, with misdiagnosis occurring in less than half the cases 12. . . .
    • . . . According to large series, confusion of AAD with acute coronary syndrome may occur in up to 45% of cases 1910 . . .
    • . . . Hansen et al underlined that the confusion of AAD with acute coronary syndrome not only does delay correct diagnosis but may prove lethal for the patient due to initiation of treatment with antithrombotic agents 1 . . .
  2. R Erbel; F Alfonso; C Boileau; O Dirsch; B Eber; A Haverich; H Rakowski; J Struyven; K Radegran; U Sechtem; J Taylor; C Zollikofer; WW Klein; B Mulder; LA Providencia Diagnosis and management of aortic dissection. Task Force Report European Heart Journal 22, 1642-1681 (2001) .
  3. DN Zull; R Cydulka Acute paraplegia: a presenting manifestation of aortic dissection Am J Med 84, 765-70 (1988) .
    • . . . The patient may present with paralysis of upper and/or lower extremities 3, anuria, dyspnea or pulmonary edema . . .
    • . . . Acute aortic dissection is associated with neurological sequella in as many as one third of patients 31516 . . .
    • . . . Painless AAD presenting as hemiplegia or paresis is a rare phenomenon, occurring in 2% to 8% of patients 31718 . . .
    • . . . Data from 1,805 patients with aortic dissection showed that 4.2% of patients presented with acute paraplegia or paraparesis 3 . . .
  4. T Shiga; Z Wajima; CC Apfel; T Inoue; Y Ohe Diagnostic accuracy of transesophageal echocardiography, helical computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging for suspected thoracic aortic dissection: systematic review and meta-analysis Arch Intern Med 166, 1350-6 (2006) .
    • . . . Moreover some of them are time-consuming or not applicable for hemodynamic unstable patients 24 . . .
    • . . . According to the relevant literature, in cases of AAD the most common symptom by far is chest pain, which is usually sharp and sometimes reported as tearing or ripping, while often radiating to the back or the abdomen 46 . . .
    • . . . This was due to the fact that aortic valve insufficiency is difficult to depict using CT 4. . . .
    • . . . Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was not the first choice of imaging modality in our Unit, because despite its high sensitivity and specificity (mean value 95%) and accuracy in confirming aortic dissection for high risk patients 422, MRI has certain limitation . . .
  5. ME De bakey; DA Cooley; OJ Creech Surgical considerations of dissecting aneurysm of the aorta Ann Surg 142, 586-610 (1955) .
    • . . . According to the De Bakey classification, aortic dissection Type I was identified in 29 patients, Type II in 14 patients and Type III in 6 patients 5. . . .
  6. PG Hagan; CA Nienaber; EM Isselbacher; D Bruckman; DJ Karavite; PL Russman; A Evangelista; R Fattori; T Suzuki; JK Oh; AG Moore; JF Malouf; LA Pape; C Gaca; U Sechtem; S Lenferink; HJ Deutsch; H Diedrichs; J Marcos y Robles; A Llovet; D Gilon; SK Das; WF Armstrong; GM Deeb; KA Eagle The international Registry of Acute Aortic Dissection (IRAD): new insights into an old disease JAMA 16, 897-903 (2000) .
    • . . . According to the relevant literature, in cases of AAD the most common symptom by far is chest pain, which is usually sharp and sometimes reported as tearing or ripping, while often radiating to the back or the abdomen 46 . . .
    • . . . Similarly, in 464 patients enrolled in the IRAD study, chest X-ray revealed no mediastinal widening or abnormality in aortic contour in 21.3% of patients 6. . . .
    • . . . In the IRAD, the first diagnostic test used was computed tomography in 61% 6 . . .
    • . . . The mortality rate associated with thoracic aortic dissection is high and has recently been reported to increase by 1% to 1.4% per hour when a patient remains untreated, leading to a 68% mortality rate in the first 48 hours 26 . . .
  7. CA Nienaber; KA Eagle Aortic Dissection: New frontiers in diagnosis and management. Part II: Therapeutic Management and Follow-Up Circulation 108, 772-778 (2003) .
    • . . . Our findings are in agreement with data from large series where up to 30% of patients with AAD, were initially given a different diagnosis 7 . . .
    • . . . Widened mediastinum in a chest X-ray is a common finding in 60% to 90% of cases of suspected AD 7, while according to Earnest et al up to 20% of chest X-rays may be negative in patients with AAD 20 . . .
  8. PC Spittell; JA Spittell; JW Joyce; AJ Tajik; WD Edwards; HV Schaff; AW Stanson Clinical features and differential diagnosis of aortic dissection: experience with 236 cases (1980 through 1990) Mayo Clin Proc 68, 642-51 (1993) .
    • . . . According to Spittell et al in 17 patients (28%) the diagnosis of AAD was not made until post-mortem examination 8. . . .
  9. ZT Liang; J Guo; XP Yu; B Zhang Analysis of misdiagnosis in 33 cases of aortic dissection Di Yi Jun Yi Da Xue Xue Bao 25, 1172-1174 (2005) .
    • . . . According to large series, confusion of AAD with acute coronary syndrome may occur in up to 45% of cases 1910 . . .
    • . . . According to Liang et al, results of CPK-MB and cardiac troponin could not discriminate between AAD and MI in a total of 33 patients who suffered from AAD, and this fact contributed to the misdiagnosis in more than half the cases 9 . . .
  10. KA Eagle; T Quertermous; GA Kritzer; JB Newell; R Dinsmore; L Feldman; RW DeSanctis Spectrum of conditions initially suggesting acute aortic dissection but with negative aortograms Am J Cardiol 57, 322-6 (1986) .
    • . . . According to large series, confusion of AAD with acute coronary syndrome may occur in up to 45% of cases 1910 . . .
  11. H Kawano; Y Tomichi; S Fukae; Y Koide; G Toda; K Yano Aortic dissection associated with acute myocardial infarction and stroke found at autopsy Intern Med 45, 957-62 (2006) .
    • . . . Kawano et al also reported a case of a patient who died of AAD while treated for MI 11 . . .
  12. H Eggebrecht; CK Naber; C Bruch; K Kröger; C von Birgelen; A Schmermund; M Wichert; T Bartel; K Mann; R Erbel Value of plasma fibrin D-dimers for detection of acute aortic dissection J Am Coll Cardiol 44, 804-9 (2004) .
    • . . . However, because it is highly elevated in both acute PE and acute AAD 12 we did not use it as first line test in the ER. . . .
  13. C Ayrik; H Cece; O Aslan; O Karcioglu; E Yilmaz Seeing the invisible: painless aortic dissection in the emergency setting Emerg Med J 23, 24 (2006) .
    • . . . Although pain is the most common presenting symptom in AAD, painless acute aortic dissection may occur in approximately 5% of patients 1314 . . .
  14. J Young; AM Herd Painless acute aortic dissection and rupture presenting as syncope J Emerg Med 22, 171-4 (2002) .
    • . . . Although pain is the most common presenting symptom in AAD, painless acute aortic dissection may occur in approximately 5% of patients 1314 . . .
  15. JL Prendes Neurovascular syndromes of aortic dissection Am Fam Physician 23, 175-9 (1981) .
    • . . . Acute aortic dissection is associated with neurological sequella in as many as one third of patients 31516 . . .
  16. SA Rosen Painless aortic dissection presenting as spinal cord ischemia Ann Emerg Med 17, 840-2 (1988) .
    • . . . Acute aortic dissection is associated with neurological sequella in as many as one third of patients 31516 . . .
  17. AG Archer; PL Choyke; RK Zeman; CE Green; M Zuckerman Aortic dissection following coronary artery bypass surgery: diagnosis by CT Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol 9, 142-5 (1986) .
    • . . . Painless AAD presenting as hemiplegia or paresis is a rare phenomenon, occurring in 2% to 8% of patients 31718 . . .
  18. AD Weisman; RD Adams The neurological complications of dissecting aortic aneurysm Brain 67, 6-91 (1944) .
    • . . . Painless AAD presenting as hemiplegia or paresis is a rare phenomenon, occurring in 2% to 8% of patients 31718 . . .
  19. EM Donovan; GK Seidel; A Cohen Painless aortic dissection presenting as high paraplegia: a case report Arch Phys Med Rehabil 81, 1436-8 (2000) .
    • . . . In this case chest CT was performed on hospital day 4, and revealed a type A dissecting aneurysm extending from the aortic valve leaflets to the take off the renal arteries 19. . . .
  20. F Earnest; JR Muhm; PF Sheedy Roentgenographic finding in thoracic aortic dissection Mayo Clin Proc 54, 43-50 (1979) .
    • . . . Widened mediastinum in a chest X-ray is a common finding in 60% to 90% of cases of suspected AD 7, while according to Earnest et al up to 20% of chest X-rays may be negative in patients with AAD 20 . . .
  21. T Sommer; W Fehske; N Holzknecht; AV Smekal; E Keller; G Lutterbey; B Kreft; C Kuhl; J Gieseke; D Abu-Ramadan; H Schild Aortic dissection: a comparative study of diagnosis with spiral CT, multiplanar transesophageal echocardiography, and MR imaging Radiology 199, 347-352 (1996) .
    • . . . CT of the thoracic aorta is currently the imaging study of choice for the evaluation of patients with suspected AAD, with its sensitivity and specificity reaching 100% 21 . . .
  22. J Golledge; KA Eagle Acute aortic dissection Lancet 372, 55-66 (2008) .
    • . . . Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was not the first choice of imaging modality in our Unit, because despite its high sensitivity and specificity (mean value 95%) and accuracy in confirming aortic dissection for high risk patients 422, MRI has certain limitation . . .
  23. CA Nienaber; KA Eagle Aortic Dissection: New frontiers in diagnosis and management. Part I: From Etiology to Diagnostic Strategies Circulation 108, 628-635 (2003) .
    • . . . These are time delay, restricted ability to monitor patient during imaging 23 and inability to be performed in hemodynamically unstable patients 2 . . .
  24. RC Bansal; K Chandrasekaran; K Ayala; DC Smith Frequency and explanation of false negative diagnosis of aortic dissection by aortography and transesophageal echocardiography J Am Coll Cardiol 25, 1393-401 (1995) .
    • . . . More importantly the diagnostic accuracy of this examination is limited 24 . . .
  25. R Erbel; R Engberding; W Daniel; J Roelandt; C Visser; H Rennollet Echocardiography in diagnosis of aortic dissection Lancet , 457-61 (1989) .
    • . . . According to the European study, sensitivity and sensitivity of coronary angiography for the diagnosis of AAD are 88% and 94% respectively 25 . . .
  26. FP Sarasin; M Louis-Simonet; JM Gaspoz; AF Junod Detecting acute thoracic aortic dissection in the emergency department: time constraints and choice of the optimal diagnostic test Ann Emerg Med 28, 278-88 (1996) .
    • . . . Therefore, prompt and accurate diagnosis and treatment decisions between surgical and conservative intervention are mandatory for reducing mortality among patients with clinically suspected thoracic aortic dissection 26. . . .
Expand